Gan: Optimizing the Production of Brassica Juncea Canola Zones, In Comparison with Other Brassica Species, in Different Soil-climatic Zones
Date: October 2008
Term: 4 years
Status: Completed
Researcher(s): Dr. Yantai Gan, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Swift Current, S.S. Mahli and H.R. Kutcher, AAFC Melfort, S. Brandt, AAFC Scott, F. Katepa-Mupondwa, AAFC Saskatoon
SaskCanola Investment: n/a
Total Project Cost: n/a
Funding Partners: ADF, AAFC Matching Investment Initiative
Project Summary
Juncea canola can be considered as an alternate oilseed crop that is adapted to the semiarid areas of the northern Great Plains where high temperature and drought stresses often limit the productivity of conventional napus and rapa canola species.
Brassica juncea canola, a relatively new oilseed species developed from Brassica juncea mustard, has an oil and meal quality equivalent to conventional canola species. Juncea canola cultivars seem to have improved phenological characteristics, such as earlier flowering, longer duration of flowering and improved drought tolerance during the reproductive growth period. These characteristics should help improve the adaptation of this new species to the drought-prone regions of the northern Great Plains.
However, it was unknown whether these characteristics of this new species would hold true under diverse environments. Also, little information was available regarding the adaptability of this crop species and its relation to nitrogen (N) use efficiency, even though this information is key in minimizing production costs and environment impacts.
Two field experiments were conducted at four sites in Saskatchewan: Melfort, Scott, Saskatoon, and Swift Current over the 2003-2006 growing seasons. For Experiment 1, the two objectives were to determine: i) yield potential and response to environmental conditions of juncea canola in different soil-climatic zones; and ii) N use efficiency (NUE), N fertilizer use efficiency (NFUE) and N uptake of juncea canola under diverse environments. Experiment 2 evaluated five canola/mustard species/cultivars to determine the difference in the degree of resistance to seed and pod shattering under straight combine versus swathing management.
In Experiment 1, five oilseed species/cultivars, including Sinapis alba yellow mustard (cv. AC Base); Brassica juncea canola (cv. Amulet); Brassica juncea condiment mustard (cv. Cutlass); Brassica rapa canola (cv. Hysyn 110); and Brassica napus hybrid canola (cv. InVigor 2663), were grown under various N fertilizer rates including 0, 25, 50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 kilgrams per hectare (kg/ha) at four sites from 2003 to 2005.
On average, alba mustard and rapa canola began flowering the earliest at 40 days after seeding (DAS), 49 DAS for napus canola (latest), and 44 DAS for juncea canola (intermediate). Flowering duration was longest for juncea canola (30 days) and shortest for napus canola (22 days). The napus canola and juncea mustard produced higher (1684 kg/ha) seed yields than the three other oilseeds (1303 kg/ha on average).
The results of this study showed that all oilseed species responded to N fertilizer rates in a similar manner, with a general trend of decreasing NUE and NFUE with increasing N fertilizer rate. The seed yield for all oilseeds was highly responsive to N fertilizer rates from zero to about 100 kg/ha, and thereafter, the rate of yield responses declined (Figure 1). The amount of N fertilizer required to achieve the maximum seed yield was 106 kg/ha for rapa canola, 135 kg/ha for alba mustard and napus canola, and 162 kg/ha for the two juncea species.
Table 1. Non-linear regression output for (A) seed and (B) straw yields produced by alba mustard (cv. AC Base), juncea canola (cv. Amulet), juncea mustard (cv. Cutlass), rapa canola (cv. Hysyn 110), and napus canola (cv. InVigor 2663). The Data were collected from 11 sites (location by year combinations) in Saskatchewan from 2003 to 2005. The trend lines were derived from predictions associated with the non-linear regression coefficients, and the vertical dash line indicates the recommended rate of N fertilizer (80 kg N/ha) for oilseed production under normal growing conditions (adapted from Gan et al., 2008b).
The seed yields of juncea canola and alba mustard were less responsive than other species/cultivars to various rates of N fertilizer, while the napus canola had the greatest yield response to increased N fertilization. Therefore, regardless of the oilseed species/cultivars, the application of adequate N fertilizers will help minimize yield variability and reduce production risks.
Experiment 1 showed that crop management practices made a significant difference in the growth and yield of juncea canola. Overall, juncea canola had lower seed yield than more popular hybrid napus canola, and the yield stability of juncea canola was lowest among the five oilseed species when examined across diverse environments. Earlier flowering, longer flowering duration, and greater tolerance to drought stress exhibited by juncea canola make the crop best adapted to the drier areas of the northern Great Plains, but the overall yield of the juncea cultivars tested in the experiment were lower than hybrid napus canola. The improvement of seed yield and yield stability will be the key to potentially adapting this new oilseed species to a wider range of environmental conditions.
In Experiment 2, plots of the five oilseeds were either swathed or desiccated with glyphosate after physiological maturity. Swathed plots were picked up and combined after windrows were dry, while desiccated plots were straight combined. All plots were combined with a plot scale combine harvester when seed had dried to near 10% seed moisture. Crops that were straight combined had greater seed yield than crops that were swathed. Juncea canola and juncea mustard produced an average of 13.7% greater seed yield when they were straight combined than when swath harvested. Straight combining of rapa canola resulted in 7.0% greater seed yield than swathing, while napus canola did not show any difference in yield between the two different operations.
Under high shattering or adverse harvesting conditions, all oilseed species/cultivars tested in the study had seed yield losses ranging from 2.4 to 7.7%, which was significantly higher than when harvesting conditions were favourable. Under high shattering conditions, there were large differences in yield loss among species during straight combining, with the yield loss the greatest for juncea mustard and napus canola; both losing >7% of the total seed yield. Yield loss was lowest for rapa (2.4%) and juncea (3.8%) canola, with alba mustard intermediate (5.2%). Under low shattering conditions, there were no significant differences among the five species/cultivars in the number of shed pods or shattered seeds, and the overall yield loss was less than 2.5% of the total seed yield.
Brassica juncea is well adapted to the drier areas of southwest Saskatchewan, such as this field at Swift Current, 2008.
Source: Yantai Gan, Swift Current Research Centre
Scientific Publications
Beckie, H.J., Johnson, E.N., Blackshaw, R.E., and Gan, Y. 2008. Weed suppression by canola and mustard cultivars. Weed Tech. 22:182–185.
Gan, Y.T., Malhi, S.S., Brandt, S.A., and McDonald, C.L. 2008a. Assessment of seed shattering resistance and yield losses in five oilseed species. Can. J. Plant Sci. 88:1-4.
Gan, Y.T., Malhi, S.S., Brandt, S.A., Katepa-Mupondwa, F. and Stevenson, C. 2008b. Nitrogen use efficiency and N uptake of juncea canola under diverse environments. Agron. J. 100:285-295.
Gan, Y.T., Malhi, S.S., Brandt, S.A., Katepa-Mupondwa, F., and Kutcher, H.R. 2007. Brassica juncea canola in the northern Great Plains: Responses to diverse environments and nitrogen fertilization. Agron. J. 99:1208-1218.
Malhi, S. S., Gan, Y.T., and Raney, J.P. 2007. Yield, seed quality, and sulfur uptake of Brassica oilseed crops in response to sulfur fertilization. Agron. J. 99: 570-577.